freakclub99 commented on…

sefs240's "The 100 Best Novels of the 20th Century"

Why? — 3 years ago

I always find it irritating to see “The Great Gatbsy” being included in the lists of great novels. I regard F. Scott Fitzgerald highy, and have heard great witticisms from him, but this book is simply immature. It has no brilliant plot; no brilliant ideas can be derived from it; and it is not even a good meditation on life. When I hear people say it is The Great American Novel, I just go like, “Are Americans that silly?” To just compare it to Melville’s masterpice, Moby Dick, makes me shudder. People please remove it from your list.


Comments

Agree...to some extent

I do think The Great Gatsby is a great novel, although I certainly agree that it is not The Great American Novel (Moby Dick, spot on). It deserves a place on the list, although top 10 does seem excessive.



or
Login with Facebook