DanBull's "Things I haven't consumed but listsofbests.com insists I have, and won't let me untick even though I didn't tick them in the first sodding place"

Instead of trying to untick the green shading go to the I have consumed this page and trying unchecking the “x” that indicates you read it, saw it, etc. This has worked for me.
Cheers!
Tassini