aptpastichecycle commented on…

Roger Ebert's "Top 10 Lists: 2000-2009"

My guess on his personal top 10 — 3 years ago

If Ebert had actually made out a top 10 of the year, instead of 35 I think his list would have gone something like this.

1. Happy-Go-Lucky

2. Milk

3. Synecdoche, NY

4. Rachel Getting Married

5. Frozen River

6. Doubt

7. Slumdog Millionaire

8. The Dark Knight

9. The Fall

10. Shotgun Stories

Not so sure about the order but I think these would be a more accurate 10 for Ebert, personally. And definitely not what I would choose, seeing as how I did not like The Fall and wasn’t crazy about Happy-Go-Lucky but I am simply basing what I would think would be Ebert’s tastes…


Comments

Sounds good

Lets compromise, I’d go:

1. Synecdoche, NY

2. Milk

3. Happy-Go-Lucky

4. Frozen River

5. Rachel Getting Married

6. Doubt

7. Slumdog Millionaire

8. Revolutionary Road

9. The Dark Knight

10. Frost/Nixon

The Fall

The reason why I said he would probably pick The Fall is because in his review he stated “This movie will be in my top 10 of the year” even though he never made a top 10, but I can see your reasoning for not including it, as it is, yes, a bad film.



or
Login with Facebook