Lists featuring In the Aeroplane over the Sea

• Pitchfork's "Top 100 Albums of the '90s [1999 version]"
• Jamie's "Best Indie Albums"
• Dieda's "Best Indie Albums"
• blondebride's "Best Indie Albums"
• thesearefables's "Best Indie Albums"
• Pitchfork's "Top 100 Albums of the 1990s [Redux]"
• File Under Popular Music (1) – 100 Greatest Albums of All Time
• marinerwarhawks's "Best Indie Albums"
• elizaveta's "Best Indie Albums"
• The Ultimate Psychedelic Rock Library
• rosebud716's "20 Favorite Albums EVER"
• TweeNet's "Top 40 albums for May 1997-July 1999"
• adjectivenoun's "Someone's 20 Favorite Albums EVER"
• digitalfruit's "20 Favorite Albums EVER"
• digitalfruit's "20 Favorite Albums EVER"
• Music
• jpreynolds1's "The 50 Greatest Albums: 1980-2005"
• jake1435's "My 40 Favorite Albums"
• theqissilent's "The 100 Best Albums of the 90s"
• Rate Your Music's Top 100 albums
• alonelyguitar's "list of favorite albums"
• Matt's "20 Favorite Albums EVER"
• puffalo's "20 Favorite Albums EVER"
• Sofia's "Desert Island Discs"
• ehkzibiht's "Because you don't have anything better to do (a list of albums that are quite good)"