Lists featuring Black Sheep Boy

• KEXP's "Top 90.3 albums of 2005"
• The Village Voice's "Best Albums of 2005 (32nd Annual Pazz & Jop Critics' Poll)"
• Metacritic's "Best Music of 2005"
• all our feelings are in our heads's "What I'm Listening To"
• Josh Mock's "Stuff to check out"
• Gobman's "Desert Island Discs"
• catchyoureye's "Music I Won't Forget (2006)"
• zalm's "Best Albums of 2005"
• RJHenn's "Top 100 Albums 1990 - 2006"
• emilybean's "My Favorite Music"
• Ianthe87's "Best Indie Albums"
• markpuck's "What I'm Listening To"
• Scott Yarbrough's "Current Music Library"
• Cokemachine Glow's Top 50 Albums of 2005
• fish_beauty's "Pop culture I consumed 2008.01.01 - 2008.12.31"
• makebelieve81's "My Favorite Music"
• The AtEase Top 1500 Albums: 2007 Edition
• Annie's "Music to buy when I finally have money again"
• Pitchfork's "Top 200 Albums of the 2000s"
• Under the Radar Magazine's Best of the 2000's
• Pitchfork Top 50 Albums of 2005
• Pitchfork's Top 50 Albums of 2005